45 Best Tomato Recipes & You Can't Tell Me Otherwise (2024)

Tomatoes for summer? Groundbreaking. But Meryl Streep jokes aside, it really is a delicious time to be alive. Growing up, I never thought much of raw tomatoes—I didn’t avoid them, per se, but I never went out of my way to seek them out. I thought it was because I just didn't like them but really, I just wasn’t eating great tomatoes. Eventually, I learned about heirloom tomatoes (ever heard of 'em?!) and then later in life, traveled to Italy where I ate fresh tomatoes daily during peak season. Now, I’ll practically eat them like an apple (try and stop me!). I put the red (or green or yellow or orange or brown-ish!) fruit to work with these 45 tomato recipes all summer long.

From Our Shop

Sale! Five Two Essential Kitchen Knives $49 $29.99 More Options Shop Now
OXO Glass Salad Spinner $64.99 Shop Now
Sale! Staub Enameled Cast-Iron Tomato Cocotte, 3QT $329.99 $249.99 More Colors Shop Now

Best Tomato Recipes forSummer

1.

Who knew that three ingredients plus barely any active work equaled the most nuanced, buttery tomato sauce out there? Don't forget bread on the side, for dipping.

2. Martha Stewart's One-Pan Pasta

Pasta brings its own sauce to the party when it cooks at the same time as cherry tomatoes, onions, garlic, and a few other friends.

Martha Stewart's One-Pan Pasta

3. Yotam Ottolenghi's Sweet Corn Polenta With Eggplant Sauce

Tomatoes (and tomato paste) deepen the flavor of the eggplant sauce that tops this fresh corn polenta.

Yotam Ottolenghi's Sweet Corn Polenta with Eggplant Sauce

4. Sarah Leah Chase's Scalloped Tomatoes

A little garlic and basil—plus bread, for sopping—make fresh tomatoes their best selves.

Sarah Leah Chase's Scalloped Tomatoes

5.

Ripe tomatoes, spaghetti, garlic, basil, and butter join forces for a speedy weeknight pasta that tastes anything but simple.

Michael Ruhlman's Pasta with Tomato Water, Basil, and Garlic

6. Alice Waters' Ratatouille

This genius ratatouille is equally perfect hot or cold, plated nicely or eaten straight from the baking dish (you know, moments after your guests leave).

Classic Ratatouille From Alice Waters

7.

This iconic no-knead dough gets topped with fresh, peeled Roma tomatoes—which, yes, you get to squeeze with your hands till they're broken down into a sauce.

Jim Lahey's No-Knead Pizza Dough + Margherita Pie

8. Ina Garten's Pasta Alla Vecchia Bettola

Ina's creamy sauce stars canned tomatoes and has a clever secret for getting them deeply jammy: oven-roasting.

Ina Garten's Pasta alla Vecchia Bettola

9.

Good luck finding a speedier—or more delicious—baked pasta.

10. Rick Bayless' Tortilla Soup With Shredded Chard

A ripe tomato gets roasted below a hot broiler until blistered, then adds lots of body to this smoky soup.

Rick Bayless' chicken Tortilla Soup with Shredded Chard

11.

Cornbread makes an appearance in this tomatoey, panzanella-like salad—oh, and the whole thing gets topped with grilled sausage.

12. Barbara Lynch's Spicy Tomato Soup

This spicy tomato soup is vegan, requires just five ingredients (psst: you probably already have them), and comes together in just about the time it'll take to decide your next Netflix binge-watch.

Barbara Lynch's Spicy Tomato Soup

13.

Leave it to Marcella (yeah, we're on a first-name basis) to make the list twice, this time with a tomatoey braised celery you're going to want to top with a crispy fried egg.

Marcella Hazan's Braised Celery with Onion, Pancetta, and Tomatoes

14. Craig Claiborne's Pasta Con Asparagi

This pasta is pretty much a highlight reel of all the best sauces, smooshed together: tomato, carbonara, and asparagus.

Craig Claiborne's Pasta con Asparagi

15.

Meet the life-changing ragu you can make completely ahead—like, up to two full days beforehand.

16. Melty Cheddar Tomatoes

In a weird, wacky turn of events, this incredible Big Little Recipe is essentially a deconstructed version of my favorite lunch: tomato soup and grilled cheese. Which is to say, tomatoes (you pick the kind you want!) are sautéed until sizzling, then covered in grated cheddar cheese.

Melty Cheddar Tomatoes

17. Tomato Soup With a Whole Head of Garlic

This recipe strays a bit from Grandma’s old-fashioned tomato soup, thanks to the use of so. much. garlic. But it’s still so easy to make—roast an onion, garlic, herbs, red chile pepper, and cherry tomatoes in the oven until charred, then blend with coconut milk and vegetable stock.

Tomato Soup With a Whole Head of Garlic

18. Grilled Marinated Tomatoes

Don’t be intimidated by the idea of grilling tomatoes—sure, it seems like they’ll probably fall apart under the heat but with recipe developer Ali Slagle’s careful instructions, you’ll have a delicious summer appetizer on your table in no time.

Grilled Marinated Tomatoes

19. Roasted Cherry Tomatoes From Adeena Sussman

These juicy, blistered tomatoes are endlessly versatile—fold them into pasta, smash them over toast smeared with ricotta or goat cheese, or sprinkle them over pizza.

Roasted Cherry Tomatoes From Adeena Sussman

20. Pasta With 10-Minute Tomato Sauce

When you’re crunched for time, quickly cooking pasta with jarred sauce seems like the best option for dinner. But you don’t need to sacrifice flavor for the sake of time with this quick and easy recipe made with three kinds of tomatoes—tomato paste, oil-packed, sun-dried tomatoes, and canned cherry tomatoes.

Pasta With 10-Minute Tomato Sauce

21. Labneh With Sizzled Tomatoes

Heirloom tomatoes are something special—from their crisp-juicy dual texture to their varied hues, they instantly make something like labneh (an already appealing spread, I might add) so much more appealing.

Labneh With Sizzled Tomatoes

22.

It’s a WFH summer lunch! A picnic lunch! A too-hot-to-turn-on-the-stove lunch! A kids-are-home-from-summer-camp lunch! A tomato galore lunch! No matter what you call it, you’ll want a slice.

23.

This is a brilliant use of tomatoes that are on their last legs. All you need are Roma tomatoes, olive oil, sea salt, and a little bit (or a lot! You pick!) of ground coriander—toss ‘em, roast ‘em, and enjoy ‘em for a few bonus days.

24. Brown Butter Tomatoes

The beauty of cooking in-season tomatoes is that you don’t need to go crazy trying to dress them up—all it takes is brown butter and flaky sea salt, says Food52 founder Amanda Hesser.

Brown Butter Tomatoes

25. Garlicky, Buttery Roasted Tomatoes

This Big Little Recipe from Emma Laperruque offers big flavor only—and yet, it’s so simple you can carry all of the ingredients in two hands (that is, if you tuck the soy sauce bottle between your pointed finger and thumb, carry a stick of salted butter between your middle and ring fingers, balance a pint of cherry tomatoes in your palm, and tuck a couple of garlic heads between the crevice of your elbow).

Garlicky, Buttery Roasted Tomatoes

26. Hasselback Caprese

You don’t really need a recipe to make a Caprese salad (if you’re struggling, just search for an image of the Italian flag and that’s all you need to know). However, we love the visual inspo from this hasselback-style salad. “Just nestle creamy mozzarella into a ripe, scored tomato, then top with fresh basil and a crunchy, spicy chile oil,” says recipe developer Marissa Mullen.

Hasselback Caprese

27.

Bookmark this for summer weekends when you have time to make your own puff pastry from scratch (you don’t need to, but frankly, you should).

28. Tomato Salad With Crispy Spiced Chickpeas

There’s a little bit of everything happening in this made-for-summer salad: crispy chickpeas, juicy tomatoes, spicy mayo, and melt-in-your-mouth shreds of cheddar cheese.

Tomato Salad With Crispy Spiced Chickpeas

29. Cherry Tomato Tarte Tatin

Calm down, apples, you’ll have your time to shine in just a few months. For now, we’re switching

Cherry Tomato Tarte Tatin

30. A Tomato Sandwich Worthy of a Little Bacon

The classic BLT got a major glow-up, due in part to a bacon-avocado aioli (you heard me) and the absolute best tomatoes you can find. No pressure.

A Tomato Sandwich Worthy of a Little Bacon

31. Crispy Farro and Tomato Salad

Grain salads tend to call for quite the extensive list of ingredients, which frankly makes me not want to cook one. This is not that. Start with pre-cooked farro (or go ahead and use quinoa if, like me, farro makes you too bloated to hang), broil it until crispy, then sprinkle it over a platter of tomatoes with Parmesan, parsley, and lemon zest.

Crispy Farro and Tomato Salad

32. Priya Krishna's Tomato-Cheese Masala Toast

“The wild card ingredient in this recipe is chaat masala, the funky, salty spice blend that brings this simple tomato-cheese toast to an entirely different level,” writes recipe developer Priya Krishna. This not-so-secret ingredient is a welcome and necessary addition to the always dependable tomato toast.

Priya Krishna's Tomato-Cheese Masala Toast

33. Halen Môn Tomato-Rosemary Focaccia

You know you’re going to stack tomatoes on a slice of homemade focaccia anyway, so why not get ahead of the game and press them directly into the dough?

Halen Môn Tomato-Rosemary Focaccia

34.

Every summer picnic requires a bucket of cold drinks, a very Dad playlist, a tomato salad, and a peach salad. This recipe offers a 2:1 special, combining the two fruits into one incredible dish.

Tomato, Peach, Chèvre, and Herb Salad with Apple Vinaigrette

35. Tomato Choka

A hybrid of East Indian and Caribbean dishes, this spicy tomato dish can be eaten any way you’d like—spoon it over burgers, eat it by the spoon, or serve it as a dip.

Tomato Choka

36. Daniel Boulud's Tomates Farcies

Don’t be intimidated by this uber-chic preparation of stuffed tomatoes filled with ground pork, bread crumbs, mushrooms, and herbs—it’s actually super simple to make!

Daniel Boulud's Tomates Farcies

37.

Admittedly, I haven’t made this recipe yet but I already know it’s going to be my new favorite dinner because of two words: crispy. gnocchi.

38.

You don’t need to spend days, weeks, or even months pickling produce. Five minutes is all it takes to quick-pickle cherry tomatoes with fennel seeds, nigella seeds, cumin seeds, black mustard seeds, and fenugreek seeds, plus a little bit of lime juice.

39.

Give tomatoes and basil a life beyond pasta—here, they’re sautéed in a mustardy brown butter sauce, which is served with baked salmon.

40.

There are no surprises hiding in this tomatoey pasta salad—what you see is what you get (feta cheese, fresh mint, orzo, green beans, and tomatoes). And yet, the superior summer flavors will still catch you by surprise.

41. Grilled Tomatoes With Bracing Vinaigrette

I know, I know, we’ve been over this already. Grilling tomatoes seems really scary but I promise you it’s not (and if a few fall through the cracks, well that’ll just give your charcoal even more flavor on the next go around).

Grilled Tomatoes With Bracing Vinaigrette

42.

When you’re looking for a classic Italian interpretation of tomatoes, basil, and garlic, this pasta dish is it.

43.

When tomato and corn seasons overlap, make this 20-minute pasta dish.

44.

Shrimp pasta is always good, but rarely inspiring; this one will transform hearts, minds, and bellies. “This recipe calls for tiny tomatoes, fresh basil, and choose-your-own chile paste (plus butter and salt). The result is spicy, saucy, and deeply savory,” writes recipe developer Emma Laperruque.

45. Pisto Manchego With Eggs

Have some fun with a bevy of summer vegetables like tomatoes, zucchini, and Italian peppers in this egg recipe.

Pisto Manchego With Eggs
How are you making use of the bounty of summer tomatoes? Let us know in the comments below.
45 Best Tomato Recipes & You Can't Tell Me Otherwise (2024)

FAQs

What is the most flavourful tomato? ›

Tomato 'Rosella Purple'

"The flavor of 'Rosella Purple' is truly outstanding," says LeHoullier. "The ability to get such flavor on a tomato plant easily grown in a 5-gallon pot on a porch or deck is a true advance in the selection of tomatoes possible for space-constrained gardens."

What are the best tomatoes to eat raw? ›

Because beefsteak tomatoes have a high-water content, they're best eaten raw in salads or sandwiches. Try slicing beefsteaks to top burgers or layer into sandwiches, such as a Classic Club Sandwich, Tomato Tea Sandwiches, or these Almost-Famous Tomato, Basil and Mozzarella Flatbread Sandwiches.

What are beefsteak tomatoes good for? ›

Beefsteak tomatoes

They're perfect to slice up for sandwiches and hamburgers. They're also mild in taste and juicy, making them a good choice for canning or sauce-making.

How do you make bad tomatoes taste good? ›

For acid, sprinkle halved or thickly sliced tomatoes with a few drops of fresh lemon juice or a quality vinegar such as Champagne, white-wine or my favorite, Sherry vinegar. For sweetness, a very tiny sprinkle of sugar will do the trick.

What is a super fantastic tomato? ›

Large, round, perfectly formed, 8-10 ounce red fruit that adapts well to all parts of the country. An outstanding early tomato that produces abundant harvests continuously until frost. An improved Fantastic tomato, with stronger disease resistance.

What are the best tasting tomatoes for sandwiches? ›

Some of the tomatoes that professional chefs and foodies prefer to use on sandwiches are:
  • The Mortgage Lifter. Big sandwiches call for big tomatoes. ...
  • The Brandywine Tomato. Another type of heirloom beefsteak tomato with a fantastic rich flavor is the Brandywine tomato. ...
  • Big Boy Tomato. ...
  • Black Krim Tomato.
Sep 6, 2023

Who should not eat raw tomatoes? ›

Due to the development of different gastric acids in the stomach, eating too many tomatoes can cause heartburn or acid reflux. Therefore, people who commonly experience stomach distress or have GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease) symptoms should limit their tomato consumption.

What is the healthiest tomato in the world? ›

That said, some varieties are naturally higher in this healthy antioxidant compound than others. Here are a few lycopene-rich tomato varieties to try: 'Crimson Cherry': Of all the tomatoes, cherry and roma varieties are the highest in lycopene, and, for us, Crimson Cherry comes top of the heap.

What are the best tomatoes for hamburgers? ›

If you're having a difficult time selecting one, the best type of tomato to use for your burger is the grape tomato. Tomatoes like beefsteak and heirloom are usually most people's go-to choices. They're not only delicious when fresh, but they're also huge, filling most if not all the circumference of the patty.

Which is better Big Boy or Better Boy tomatoes? ›

Things such as better disease resistance, color, meatiness, size and ease of growth. The Better Boy's parents are the Big Boy and the Lemon Boy. They are still available and popular in their own right, but the Better Boy has surpassed both in popularity with commercial and individual producers.

What is the best tomato to use for salsa? ›

Roma Tomatoes are a popular choice for salsa-making due to their dense and meaty texture, small number of seeds, and full-of-flavor tanginess. Variations of this tomato are sometimes called “plum” or “paste” tomatoes. Red Beefsteak Tomatoes are another favorite for those who favor a juicier tomato in their salsa.

Does Epsom salt make tomatoes taste better? ›

Fact! Adding Epsom salts to your plant either through foliar spray or direct watering is a great way of boosting micronutrient absorption. This helps your tomato plant produce large, juicy, and very sweet fruits. Remember that a little bit goes a long way and too much can cause more problem than it fixes.

What enhances the flavor of tomatoes? ›

Yes, there are other ways to make your tomatoes taste even better and increase the acidity. There is lemon, vinegar, or my personal favorite, balsamic. Just imagine a tomato bruschetta with a balsamic vinaigrette drizzled on top. Yummy!

What does cream of tartar do to tomatoes? ›

This ingredient hidden at the back of your spice cabinet helps tomatoes strike the perfect balance of sweetness and acidity.

What is the best-tasting slicing tomato? ›

Heirloom tomatoes are delicious in any dish, and in addition to being one of the best-tasting tomatoes, many cooks consider them the best slicing tomato because of their unique colors.

What are the best-tasting tomatoes for cooking? ›

ROMA. Romas are dense, Italian plum tomatoes with a low-seed count and a firm, flavorful flesh, making them (tied with San Marzanos) the undisputed choice for tomato sauces, tomato pastes, and the like. SAN MARZANO.

What's the sweetest tasting tomato? ›

'Golden Sweet': Touted as the sweetest and best-tasting yellow grape tomato, the indeterminate vines produce lots of glossy gold fruits that are crack-resistant, firm and meaty. 2. 'Isis Candy': This is a very pretty cherry tomato with golden fruits streaked with red.

What is the sweetest best-tasting tomato? ›

1. Sungold Cherry Tomatoes: These bright orange cherry tomatoes are absolutely sweet and delicious! They have a Brix rating of 8.5 and are perfect for snacking on or adding to salads. It is small in size, and has a sweet flavor.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 5807

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.